# Is Colorful Vinyl legit? Yes. Colorful Vinyl is a working online record shop at [colorfulvinyl.com](https://colorfulvinyl.com/?utm_source=colorfulvinylreviews&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=legit), and its buyers have left 59 reviews averaging 4.76 out of 5. Here is the evidence, including the orders that went wrong. ## The short answer Colorful Vinyl sells rare, limited and colored vinyl through its own store at [colorfulvinyl.com](https://colorfulvinyl.com/?utm_source=colorfulvinylreviews&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=legit). Between March 2023 and December 2025, buyers left 59 reviews through Loox, the store’s review app. 53 are five stars, and 57 are tied to a verified purchase. ## What the reviews show - **Average rating:** 4.76 out of 5 across 59 reviews - **Five-star reviews:** 53 of 59 - **Verified purchases:** 57 of 59 - **Records reviewed:** 48 different releases - **Most mentioned:** shipping and delivery (34 reviews), condition and accuracy (25), packaging (16) ## When an order went wrong 6 reviews are under five stars. Where the problem was the shop’s to fix, the reviews and the shop’s replies show what happened next. > Wrong one received > > Elena M., 1 out of 5, Mar 1, 2024. Taylor Swift, Evermore (Deluxe) (Green Vinyl). > > Colorful Vinyl replied: We have provided a full refund. > I haven’t got it yet > > Richard, 1 out of 5, Jul 2, 2023. St. Vincent, Daddy’s Home (Gray Vinyl). > > Colorful Vinyl replied: This customer received a full refund. > My package unfortunately arrived to me damaged due to USPS handling, but a representative from Colorful Vinyl was able to ship out a new one for me right away! Very thankful for their customer service. > > Dylan C., 5 out of 5, Nov 28, 2024. Taylor Swift, Folklore (In the Weeds Green Vinyl). > To update my previous review, they reached out to me and make the transaction right. The album is beautiful and unique and I get so many compliments on it and I’ve only had it since Christmas. > > Courtney P., 4 out of 5, Jan 17, 2025. Wicked Movie Cast, Wicked: The Soundtrack (Picture Disc Vinyl). > Communication with Michael at colorful vinyl records was great. There was a delay in the order and he communicated and they came through. Daughter loves the record! Thanks again! > > David B., 5 out of 5, Jan 5, 2025. Billie Eilish, Hit Me Hard and Soft (Blue Vinyl). The other low reviews mention a bent cover, a damaged case edge (from the buyer who later updated the review above) and a small tear in an inner sleeve. All of them are on the [home page](https://colorfulvinylreviews.com/#low-title), unedited. ## Buyers who were unsure at first > I really loved the service that Colorful Vinyl Records provided. The record came fast and it was as expected from the website. I was skeptical at first but they have proved to be reliable and trustworthy. I will be purchasing more and more. Thank you so much! > > Ny’Dajah J., 5 out of 5, Jan 13, 2025. Beyoncé, Lemonade (Yellow Vinyl). > I received the album in about two weeks. Due to prior reviews I was nervous but it all worked out okay! I moved recently so I haven’t gotten around to opening the vinyl itself yet and seeing it. > > McKenna P., 5 out of 5, Feb 1, 2025. The Kooks, Inside In / Inside Out (Red Vinyl). > I've ordered from Colorfulvinyl on ebay and was excited to find there website! Vinyl was shipped super quick, packaged securely and the vinyl came brand new looking absolutely perfect! Great experience! > > Sarah O., 5 out of 5, Oct 14, 2023. Taylor Swift, Folklore (Running Like Water Silver Vinyl). ## What this page can’t tell you - Colorful Vinyl publishes this site, so read it as the shop’s own record of its reviews, not an independent verdict. - Every number here comes from one source, the Loox reviews on colorfulvinyl.com. Feedback from other marketplaces is not counted or blended in. - The data runs to the Loox export of July 2, 2026. Newer reviews show up on colorfulvinyl.com first. ## Before you buy Check the listing for the exact variant and its condition notes, and compare the price with recent sales of the same pressing. [Pricing and condition](https://colorfulvinylreviews.com/pricing-and-condition/) covers what to look for.